---
title: A CHEFS RESPONSE & why I love;   Look out, Bone Broth; Mushroom Broth.......by Michelle Rabin
description: Botanical Kitchen's response on mushroom broth as the new magical bone broth article by Michelle Rabin from The Modern Farmer.
image: https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hubfs/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-07%20at%209.20.05%20AM-1.png
---

[![Botanical Kitchen](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hubfs/Botanical-Main-logo.png)](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/)

- [RECIPES](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/recipe_category/)
- [MEMBERSHIPS](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-botanical-kitchen-membership/) 
    - [Chef’s Table](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/patch-to-plate-weekly-menus/)
    - [Whole Plant Life](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/whole-plant-life/)
    - [About Memberships](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-botanical-kitchen-membership/) 
          - [Free Trial Chefs Table](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/register/patch-to-plate/)
          - [Free Trial Plant Life](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/register/whole-plant-life/)
    - [GIft Chef's Table](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/register/gift-patch-to-plate/)
    - [Gift Whole Plant Life](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/register/gift-whole-plant-life/)
    - [Membership FAQs](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/membership-faqs/)
- PROGRAMS 
    - [ABOUT 14 DAY RESET](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/14-day-reset-program-about/) 
          - [Register Chef Table](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/chefs-table-14-day-food-as-medicine-reset-register/)
          - [Register Plant Life](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/whole-plant-life-14-day-food-as-medicine-reset-register/)
    - [Start Reset](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/14-day-reset-program-start/)
    - [1:1 Private Consultations](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/functional-nutrition-consultation/)
- [ABOUT](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-company/) 
    - [Botanical Kitchen](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-company/)
    - [Karina Hines](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-karina-hines/)
    - [Kitchen Journal Blog](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/)
    - [Project Portfolio](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/project-portfolio/)
- [CLASSES + EVENTS](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/media-events/)
- [SHOP](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/shop-supplements-and-herbals/) 
    - [Supplements](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/shop-supplements-and-herbals/)
    - [Natural Body & Beauty](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/shop-body-and-beauty/)
- CONTACT 
    - [Contact us](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/contact/)
    - [Media Kit](https://info.botanicalkitchen.com/mediakit-0)
    - [References](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/bibliography/)

- [Login](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/login)

![basket of veg photo finish](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hs-fs/hubfs/basket%20of%20veg%20photo%20finish.jpg?width=2000&height=1333&name=basket%20of%20veg%20photo%20finish.jpg "basket of veg photo finish")

# BOTANICAL KITCHEN BLOG

Some additional information in one line

- Print

## BOTANICAL KITCHEN BLOG

# A CHEFS RESPONSE & why I love;   Look out, Bone Broth; Mushroom Broth.......by Michelle Rabin

Authored by:

Karina Hines

![different mushrooms dark background herb flowers](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hubfs/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-07%20at%209.20.05%20AM-1.png)

![different mushrooms dark background herb flowers](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-07%20at%209.20.05%20AM-1.png?width=2699&name=Screen%20Shot%202019-02-07%20at%209.20.05%20AM-1.png)

Photography Peter Oslanec

I absolutely LOVE this article from [Modern Farmer blog](https://modernfarmer.com/2019/02/look-out-bone-broth-mushroom-broth-might-be-even-more-magical/?fbclid=IwAR14mcq0aF19WVl-5mo-83S5sGBqzdKv1XwAGTmRFGGdBNW1G_wmrSMMuJE&utm_content=84478664&utm_medium=social&utm_source=linkedin&hss_channel=lis-BAoJ0DRFRQ) written by [Michelle Rabin](https://modernfarmer.com/author/mrabin/).    

It is wonderful food for thought in different ways: one is how health food trends can really explode and become very powerful marketing driven selling tools and the other is, where is this food coming from and is there an alternative to consider?   Click [link](https://modernfarmer.com/2019/02/look-out-bone-broth-mushroom-broth-might-be-even-more-magical/?fbclid=IwAR14mcq0aF19WVl-5mo-83S5sGBqzdKv1XwAGTmRFGGdBNW1G_wmrSMMuJE&utm_content=84478664&utm_medium=social&utm_source=linkedin&hss_channel=lis-BAoJ0DRFRQ) here.

My motto when it comes to animal products is this; "Eat what you like but first know where your food comes from and the truth about how it is really produced".

This healing bone broth that one can now buy in all forms, from glass bottles to tetrapak to powder form, gives me pause to wonder what was the health and wellness of these animals and their "bones" before they were brewed up in gigantic cauldrons and then pasteurized, pressurized or dried?  Bone broth surely can only be all-healing when it comes from a vibrant healthy source, otherwise it potentially could be a concentration of toxins both environmental and pharmaceutical all packaged in a container with a pretty label picturing a few blades of grass and a smiling animal?

Bone broth is healing, no question, it has been used as tonic medicine for centuries traditionally brewed on a stove top by a cook or practitioner who was in relationship with and knowledgeable about the farm, farmer and animal whose bones they were boiling up for medicine......certainly food for thought!

[Michelle Rabin's](https://modernfarmer.com/author/mrabin/) article speaks of the wonderful healing qualities of mushrooms as another century old healing and strengthening tonic. The difference now-a-days is mushrooms still grow in a somewhat natural state. We farm them, but only in an environment in which they want to grow.  The process is natural; mushrooms are fungi they don't want or need much to grow beyond optimum temperature and moisture and a simple stable food source.

If I was going to boil up an all-heal tonic, I would put my money and my health with the fungi first unless I knew all about "those bones". To truly eat all-healing food, we really need to know about our food source.

Thanks to [Modern Farmer](https://modernfarmer.com/2019/02/look-out-bone-broth-mushroom-broth-might-be-even-more-magical/?fbclid=IwAR14mcq0aF19WVl-5mo-83S5sGBqzdKv1XwAGTmRFGGdBNW1G_wmrSMMuJE&utm_content=84478664&utm_medium=social&utm_source=linkedin&hss_channel=lis-BAoJ0DRFRQ) and [Michelle](https://modernfarmer.com/author/mrabin/) for a great article!

 

 

 Topics: [Health](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/tag/health)

OUR FOOD AS MEDICINE RECIPES

SHOPPING LIST AT A GLANCE

## Something Powerful

### Tell The Reader More

The headline and subheader tells us what you're offering, and the form header closes the deal. Over here you can explain why your offer is so great it's worth filling out a form for.

Remember:

- Bullets are great
- For spelling out benefits and
- Turning visitors into leads.

SHOPPING LIST AT A GLANCE

## Something Powerful

### Tell The Reader More

The headline and subheader tells us what you're offering, and the form header closes the deal. Over here you can explain why your offer is so great it's worth filling out a form for.

Remember:

- Bullets are great
- For spelling out benefits and
- Turning visitors into leads.

SHOPPING LIST AT A GLANCE

## Something Powerful

### Tell The Reader More

The headline and subheader tells us what you're offering, and the form header closes the deal. Over here you can explain why your offer is so great it's worth filling out a form for.

Remember:

- Bullets are great
- For spelling out benefits and
- Turning visitors into leads.

- Print

![root-vegetable_cta_banner-scaled](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hubfs/root-vegetable_cta_banner-scaled.jpg "root-vegetable_cta_banner-scaled")

weekly news ![](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/heart-1.png)letter

join patch to PLATE membership

[![June 1st 2021](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/4492132/bfea87df-b3f1-48c3-9757-21315d42e57a.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/4492132/bfea87df-b3f1-48c3-9757-21315d42e57a)

![BK logo in white](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/hubfs/BK%20logo%20in%20white.png "BK logo in white")

### Food is a Powerful Tool in Healthcare

Receive our Food as Medicine Newsletter.

### Pages

- [Home](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/)
- [About Us](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-company/)
- [Membership Plans](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/about-botanical-kitchen-membership/)
- [Recipes](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/recipe_category/)
- [Media & Events](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/media-events/)
- [Contact Us](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/contact/)
- [Blog](https://blog.botanicalkitchen.com/)
- [Membership FAQs](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/membership-faqs/)
- [References](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/bibliography/)

### Legal

- [Terms](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/terms-and-conditions/)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/privacy-policy/)

### Follow Us

<https://www.instagram.com/botanicalkitchen.eat/?hl=en> <https://www.facebook.com/botanicalkitchen.eat/> <https://www.linkedin.com/in/karina-hines-80975b162/> [![](https://www.botanicalkitchen.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/substrack-white-icon.png)](https://substack.com/@karinahinesbotanicalkitchen)

Copyright © 2026. Botanical Kitchen. \*The information on this website is for educational purposes and is not intended to diagnose, treat, prevent, or cure any disease or been evaluated by the FDA.